Rules of Arranagement by Maren Mackenzie
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of Rules of Arrangement in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
The Gist
Rules of Arrangement by Maren Mackenzie is an addictively readable debut that blends romance and emotional tension with a twist of mystery. The story follows Adelaide Wright, a college senior juggling coursework, grief, and financial pressure. Her secret side hustle—writing papers for classmates—keeps her afloat, until Declan, a former flame and her art history TA, discovers the scheme. Instead of reporting her, he ropes her into a high-stakes plan: infiltrate the world of wealthy art dealer Jack Nolan to retrieve stolen artwork.
The Details
What begins as a calculated arrangement quickly evolves into something far messier. Jack is magnetic, charming, and morally gray. Adelaide, drawn in by his world and his presence, finds herself torn between loyalty, survival, and desire. Their relationship pulses with tension and slow-burning chemistry, bringing the kind of romantic suspense that makes you keep flipping pages.
The novel excels in atmosphere and pacing. Mackenzie writes with clarity and control, keeping the story tightly focused on Adelaide’s perspective. It’s easy to root for her, even when her choices are questionable. Her emotional arc—shaped by loss, estrangement, and the need to prove herself—feels genuine and well-paced.
While the romance is a clear highlight, some side characters fall flat. Adelaide’s friendships, though mentioned, lack depth and closure. A few key relationships seem to vanish without consequence, which leaves parts of the story feeling slightly unfinished. The ending also comes faster than expected, with several threads tied up a bit too neatly.
Still, the book never loses momentum. Adelaide’s voice remains sharp and engaging, and her interactions with Jack are electric. There’s a satisfying blend of vulnerability and resolve in how she navigates her choices, making her a heroine you won’t easily forget.
The Verdict
Rules of Arrangement is a fresh, emotionally rich romance with just enough edge to keep things interesting. It doesn’t reinvent the genre, but it hits the right notes with confidence and style. For fans of romantic tension, flawed heroines, and morally complicated love interests, this one is well worth your time.
